Fish heads for Rosh Hashanah? Make super-nutritious fish soup

Drawing of a fish

Fish drawing

One of the customs of the first night of Rosh Hashanah is to eat a number of foods that symbolically represent our concerns and hopes for a good judgment for the upcoming year. Among these foods is the head of a fish (or sheep) over which we say a short prayer before eating it, asking that we be the head and not the tail. So I thought that it might be helpful to have a fish soup recipe made with the heads of fish. (You can also use the rest of the skeleton but on Rosh Hashanah you really want just the head!)

If you are going to buy whole fresh fish for the holiday be sure to ask for the heads (intact, not cleaned out) for which you are paying anyway. (Learn how to buy fresh fish in Israel here.) A little while ago I had gone into the fish store and the woman ahead of me was buying several fresh fish but did not want the heads even though she was paying for them with the purchase of the entire fish. I asked for them and got about 8 heads (for free with the woman’s agreement) that I made into nourishing fish soup. (Non-fatty fish is said to be best for fish stock.) When the bones are allowed to simmer for a few hours, especially with the addition of an acidic liquid to help draw out the calcium better, the stock becomes a veritable gold mine of nutrition and a great boost to health.

In fact, fish stock is said to be the most nutritious of all the bone broths. According to a South American proverb: “Fish broth will cure anything”. Stock contains minerals and trace minerals in a form that is easily usable by the body and fish stock in particular since it also contains iodine when made from heads; iodine is necessary for proper thyroid function. The breakdown of cartilage and tendons yields nutrients like chondroitin sulfate and glucosamine, important for joint health. And when the broth cools and gels that is because of the presence of gelatin which has been acclaimed to be a most nutritious food, important for digestive health, a protein sparer (making it a good way to make a meal from just a little meat), and useful in the treatment of many ailments.

Here’s how I make the fish stock and soup:


Into an 8 quart stock pot:

  • Place at least 3-5 fish heads depending upon size (also skeleton if not for Rosh Hashanah); 2 heads if the heads are very large. I like there to be enough to more than cover the bottom of the pot.
  • Fill the pot with filtered water to about 1 – 1 ½ inches from the top.
  • Add Apple Cider Vinegar (about ½ cup) to help leach the calcium and other minerals from the bones. My family doesn’t like the vinegar taste so I either use white wine which is also acidic, or nothing.
  • Let the water come to a gentle boil and skim off the scum that forms on top.
  • After the scum is removed, lower the fire so that it just simmers, and let it cook for about 4 hours.
  • When the stock is finished, remove the heads and take off the meat from the bones. Remove the heads one at a time to work on. Once out of the soup the bones fall apart and it makes it very tedious to remove the meat. This is especially true if you are not going to remove the meat right away. Leave the fish in the stock until you are ready to remove the meat.
  • I put the meat back into the soup. Very often I have more meat than I want in the soup so I freeze some of it and put it into additional batches of soup when using up the frozen stock or to make more fish soup after the stock is finished.

Vintage drawing cooking soupSoup (one version, feel free to experiment):


  • Olive oil (Learn more about choosing olive oil here.)
  • 2 large onions
  • Sea salt
  • Parsley  (fresh or dried)
  • Oregano (fresh or dried)
  • Dill (fresh or dried)
  • Other herbs and spices according to your taste (optional)
  • 2 to 3 large tomatoes
  • 2 large zucchini
  • 2 cloves of garlic (or to taste) minced or chopped (Learn about choosing garlic here.)
  • Coconut milk/cream (optional) (Learn more about buying coconut milk/cream here.)
  • Fish meat that was removed from the bones.
  • Sea Salt

To prepare:

  • Sautee the onions in olive oil until soft and sweet. Add some sea salt to help break down the cell walls to extract water and flavor.
  • Add the herbs and spices (except for the garlic) and let cook for a few minutes until soft
  • Add tomatoes and zucchini and let cook till soft
  • Add the garlic – do not cook for more than 20 minutes or you will lose some of the garlic’s nutritive value. Or, you can add the garlic after you’ve finished cooking the soup.
  • When finished add the vegetables to the stock
  • Add about a cup of the fish meat you took off the bones to the stock as well
  • If you like you can add coconut milk. I generally use about half a can, but the amount depends on your taste (and how much room is left in the pot).
  • Add sea salt to taste
  • Take a hand blender and blend the soup. I like to make sure everything is chopped up, but you may like to leave some larger pieces as well.

Note: Any bones left in the fish meat will fall to the bottom

If you do not want to make the entire pot of stock into soup, you can freeze some of the stock, and have it at hand when you are ready to make the next batch of soup.

Have a Happy & Healthy New Year

References and resources:

Broth is Beautiful
The Secret of Fish Stock
How to Make Homemade Fish Broth or Stock (+ Video)

Related Articles:

Cognitive performance among the elderly and dietary fish intake: the Hordaland Health Study



Tagged with: , , , ,

Amazing Pomegranates: Rosh Hashanah Specialty, Nutritional Powerhouse

Painting of Pomegranates by Leah Laker

Painting of Pomegranates by Leah LakerRimonim/Pomegranates – Painting by Leah Laker

Your lips are like a thread of scarlet, your speech is beautiful.
Your cheeks are like a piece of pomegranate from behind your veil.

                                                                          Song of Songs 4:3

The Pomegranate – special to Israel and an Israeli specialty

The pomegranate (רימון – rimon) is one of the seven species (שבעת המינים – shivat haminim) identified in the Torah (Deut. 8.8)  with which the Land of Israel is blessed and which were staple foods in Israel during biblical times (the others being wheat, barley, grapes, figs, pomegranates, olive oil, and honey). The pomegranate, found growing in gardens and sold in stores all over Israel, is immensely enjoyed fresh when in season, and as juice during the whole year. (Be sure to get only pure, non-sweetened juice, preferably unpasteurized. If you juice your own you will be sure to preserve all the health benefits since it won’t be pasteurized.) And best of all, it is a nutritional powerhouse.

Growing up in the Northeast United States, the pomegranate was a novelty for me. Its foremost purpose was to be the “new fruit”, a fruit not eaten since the beginning of its growing season, that we enjoyed on the second night of Rosh Hashanah when the blessing of Shehecheyanu was said. Truth be told, I was rather disappointed with it; it was a messy, hard to eat fruit that squirted you with red liquid when you tried to suck the juice out of the arils, those clear sacks filled with red liquid surrounding a pit, which you of course spit out. After all, who eats pits?

Seemingly more prevalent in Israel than in the United States, is the custom of eating special, symbolic foods on the first night of Rosh Hashana (some eat them both nights) as signs of a blessed new year. Apple in honey, Pomegranate, and GrapesWhile in the States we always dipped the apple in honey for a sweet new year, and some people may have eaten the head of a fish as a sign that we should be the head and not the tail, most Ashkenazim didn’t do much more. In Israel, the custom to eat about 10 special foods at the start of the meal with special blessings for each is much more common, even among Ashkenazim. The pomegranate is one of these symbolic foods and the blessing we say expresses the wish that our merits should be plentiful like (the seeds of) a pomegranate. The pomegranate, for the majority of Israelis, is not a “new fruit”!

Physical and spiritual health benefits of pomegranates

When we first moved to Israel, I was amazed to see pomegranates growing in people’s gardens; it took a while till I began to eat them in salads, pits and all. It was a few years later, however, when I read the Mishpacha Magazine article, 7 on Seven Ruby Bottles of Mitzvos, about a group of Jewish women in the UK who prepare pomegranate juice for people undergoing chemotherapy, that my perspective changed and I began to really appreciate them and anticipate their seasonal appearance in the stores.

I was amazed by the tremendous health benefits the article attributed to the pomegranate. This anecdote in particular wowed me:

When her close relative … was diagnosed with cancer five years ago, Ita Rivka was dismayed by the debilitating effects of chemotherapy on his body. Treatment left him weakened, with a fragile immune system and skin stained a pallid yellow. When she heard about the benefits of pomegranates, especially for cancer patients, Ita Rivka requested juice from a London pomegranate juice gemach. Moshe drank two bottles. Within two days, he said he “felt amazing.”

Indeed, – a popular health website with a database of research and articles, gleaned from mainstream medical journals – describes pomegranates as having over one hundred recorded health benefits!

Pomegranates help with everything from fighting serious viral and bacterial infections to reducing oxidative stress, from inducing programmed cell death in a variety of cancer cells to protecting the skin from photo-aging.

Especially noteworthy is the pomegranate’s ability to support the ovaries as a natural form of ‘hormone replacement therapy,’ especially as one gets older, and its ability to reverse plaque build-up in the arteries (atherosclerosis) – a condition which underlies heart disease. In addition, it has been found that pomegranate can also help Type 2 diabetics.

Pomegranates have also been associated with increasing fertility, helping improve fertility, and benefiting  individuals participating in performance sports.

Pomegranate juice has very high levels of many antioxidants, as well as high levels of Vitamins C & E, folate, potassium, Vitamin K, calcium, iron, phosphorus, and more flavonoids and polyphenols than grapes. According to some scientific research, pomegranate juice raises hemoglobin levels, boosts iron, improves heart health, aids the digestive system, and may fight cancer.

The Weston Price Foundation’s article, Who Needs Soda Pop with these Bodacious Beverages, suggests several ways to enjoy the juice, including fermenting the juice or peels for a delightful beverage, which would make the pomegranate’s already robust health profile even more so.

And, since pomegranate pits are high in fiber, even the pits are good for you.

Pomegranate growingAnother rich source of information about the pomegranate and its importance to both health and Judaic ritual is the wonderful book The Seven Fruits of the Land of Israel: With their Mystical and Medicinal Properties, by Chana Bracha Siegelbaum. It is filled with medical and spiritual aspects and recipes related to the Seven Species. Three interesting things I learned about the pomegranate (among many others) are:

  1. In Chinese medicine the peel, bark, and root of the pomegranate are used for healing purposes! (p. 234)
  2. The pomegranate develops from a flower that has the shape of the Star of David, which then takes on the shape of a crown as the fruit grows. In Hebrew the Star of David is known as a Magen David – Shield of David. The pomegranate boosts our immune system and shields us from illness. (p.235)
  3. The crown (כֶּתֶר – keter) of the pomegranate is compared to the Sefira Keter, the highest of the Ten Sefirot or Divine emanations. Keter is the manifestation of our true willpower and a reflection of the Divine will. When we are in touch with our true Divine will then our immune system is strengthened to fight our opponents. (p. 235)

You can remove the pomegranate’s arils without making a mess!

The easiest way to deseed a pomegranate is to score it several times  from top to bottom with a sharp knife, being careful to cut through the peel only, so that you have formed several sections. Cut off the top of the pomegranate to reveal the seeds and throw away the top. Pull the pomegranate apart in sections following the sections defined by the white membrane. You can then turn the pomegranate sections over a bowl, one by one, pull away the membrane and let the seeds drop into the bowl.

Alternatively, cut the pomegranate in half across its equator, turn it over a bowl and bang it with a wooden spoon. The seeds should fall out easily.

If you have more than you need at the time, simply store them in the refrigerator or freezer if you will not be using them shortly.

Whether you are having your pomegranate for a “ new fruit” or one of the simanim this coming Rosh Hashana, you can be sure that you are reaping tremendous blessings – both spiritual and physical.



The Seven Fruits of the Land of Israel book coverThe Seven Fruits of the Land of Israel
with their Mystical & Medicinal Properties

by Chana Bracha Siegelbaum






Tagged with: , , , , , ,

Why Some Israeli Yogurts Aren’t Really Yogurt

There was a surprise in store for me when I scrutinized the yogurt (יוֹגוּרט – yogurt) container.  What I discovered might surprise you, too.

In the United States in the late ’70s, Dannon yogurt featured commercials extolling the longevity of Soviet Georgians who ate plenty of yogurt. The takeaway, of course, was that if you eat yogurt you will be enhancing your longevity. These commercials helped to propel the growth of the yogurt industry in the USA.

Whether or not eating yogurt regularly is the main reason that these people were purported to live long and healthy lives, yogurt, a fermented food, is supposed to be rich in probiotics; probiotics are important components of healthy gut flora and critical for both physical and mental health. Several European countries include yogurt or beneficial microbes in their dietary guidelines. In fact “…”yoghurt” was defined in 1925 and specifies a typical milk fermented with Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus.”[1] Most people I know also associate it with probiotics and consume it with that intention or expectation.

When I went food shopping after we first made aliyah, I noticed that there was yogurt and there was bio (pronounced beeyo by Israelis) yogurt. I had never seen it labeled as “bio” in the States. Not considering that there might be a real difference between the two that would actually matter to me, I never checked it out. And while we preferred the goat and sheep yogurt sold in the Organic Market near us (which happened to be bio), since even yogurts sold in the health food stores are not necessarily organic, we also bought other plain, unflavored sheep yogurt (יוגורט כבשים – yogurt cvasim), goat yogurt (יוגורט עיזים – yogurt eezeem), and cow yogurt (generally just labeled as yogurt).

This all ended the other day, however. I was looking at the ingredients (רכיבים – richivim) on the container we had in the house and I realized, that aside from milk, there were no other ingredients listed. Having noticed on occasion the inclusion of probiotics in the ingredients of other brands, I called the company to inquire. And that’s how I learned that (at least in Israel) if it’s not bio yogurt and lists probiotics as an ingredient, it has no probiotics in it! In other words, if it doesn’t say “bio” on the label, then by definition, it is not yogurt.

While the websites of some commercial brands of bio yogurt sold in Israel don’t say which probiotics are contained in theirs, the website for Halav Haaretz, the brand that we usually buy in the health food (and other) stores, lists as their probiotics the two strains of bacteria, Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. Bulgaricus, which are included in the definition  above.

Yogurt containers showing ingredients

Note the difference in ingredients:  the blue container only lists sheep milk (חלב כבשים) while the green and white container lists both sheep milk and probiotic bacteria (חיידקי יוגורט). 

I’m done with the fake yogurts – are you?

[1] Probiotics in dietary guidelines and clinical recommendations outside the European Union 

Related Articles:
Are Your Gut Microflora Doing the Happy Dance?

Lactobacillus Bulgaricus and Streptococcus Thermophilus Yogurt Benefits

Tagged with: , , , ,

Are Your Gut Microflora Doing the Happy Dance?

cartoon of bacteria

cartoon of bacteria

Did you know that inside your intestinal walls is a humongous community of microflora that largely determines your health? It’s true. While we think that the food we eat is just for us, we are really feeding a whole little world inside our guts that impacts our physical and mental health!

I was recently watching several of the online Microbiome Medicine Summit presentations where a number of different medical and holistic practitioners discussed the gut microbiome over a series of days. While I knew that the bacteria that reside in our gut are critical to our health and mental well being I was surprised to learn that in addition to bacteria, there are lesser populations of fungi, viruses, and protozoa residing in our intestinal tract which also play important roles in promoting good health. Together these microflora form the gut microbiota and their genes form the gut microbiome. It’s not just our genes that inform our health and well-being but, perhaps more importantly, the genes of the 10-100 trillion microbiota that reside in our intestinal tract.

I also learned that while the human genome is about 99% identical among individuals, 95% of gut microbiota varies depending on the individual’s geographic location. Through further research I discovered that, in general, there is also an 80-90% variation in the gut microbiota among individuals, [1] and that while the composition of the gut microbiota is largely influenced by diet, these microbes are interdependent, influencing the predominance and/or activity of others and, collectively, our health.[2]

Understanding the role of our microbiome, which is almost like another body organ, and keeping it in good shape are, therefore, very important keys to health and longevity. Although researchers are beginning to study other microbiota in depth, currently, it is the bacteria with which we are most familiar and have the most information.

Bacteria can be either helpful or harmful. Depending on a variety of factors, we may colonize more or less of different types. Beneficial bacteria prevent detrimental bacteria from proliferating; are instrumental in the breaillustration of microflora in the intestineskdown/digestion of our foods and turning their components into products our body can use; produce numerous vitamins, amino acids, and other active substances; support our immune system; and have a major impact on our moods and mental health. You might be surprised to learn that almost 90% of the “feel good” brain neurotransmitter serotonin is produced in the gut and that microflora are critical to sufficient production.[3]

Beneficial bacteria are introduced to a baby’s system as it travels down the birth canal and in the breast milk it drinks (there are bacteria in both) in order to populate his/her gut with balanced, healthy microflora that should ideally last a lifetime. (Some formula manufacturers have begun adding probiotics to their formulas.)

Unfortunately, a number of different factors negatively affect gut flora, causing detrimental bacteria to proliferate or a reduction in the number and diversity of bacteria, resulting in improper or incomplete breakdown of foods, autoimmunity, inflammation, cancer, and unwanted psychological and behavioral symptoms.

Many of us take probiotics during and after a course of antibiotics thinking that this will put back the microflora the antibiotics have destroyed. However, studies such as the following have shown that antibiotics do long-term harm to our systems and sometimes these changes are permanent.

Antibiotics are mainly used to combat pathogenic bacterial species that reside within or have invaded a host, however the current generation of antibiotics are broad spectrum and target broad swaths of the normal microbiota as well. Thus, antibiotics significantly affect the host’s innate gut microbiota. Three to four days after treatment with the broad-spectrum antibiotic ciprofloxacin the gut microbiota experience a decrease in taxonomic richness, diversity, and evenness. The large magnitude of changes in the gut microbiota demonstrated significant interpersonal variability. While the gut microbiota began to resemble its pre-treatment state a week after treatment, differences between individuals were seen with regards to how closely the post-treatment community resembled the pre-treatment community, and some taxa failed to return to the community. Indeed, the reestablishment of some species can be affected for up to four years following antibiotic treatment.[4]

Image of Gut and Psychology Syndrome Book CoverDr. Natasha Campbell-McBride, in her book Gut and Psychology Syndrome (GAPS), discusses the role that not only antibiotics, but other drugs, poor diet, disease, stress, and other factors play in negatively affecting gut microflora. And she points out that these negative influences on the gut microbiome have a far greater affect than most of us have ever imagined:

Every one of us carries a unique mixture of microbes in the gut. Under the influence of drugs and other factors… this gut flora will be changed in a unique way in every one of us, predisposing us to different health problems… This damage gets passed from generation to generation as a newborn child gets its gut flora from the mother. And as the damage is passed through generations, it gets deeper and deeper.[5]

So what are we to do if we want to maintain (or regain) our health and that of our children and pass down a better heritage to future generations? While individuals with specific digestive issues such as SIBO and IBS may have disease specific requirements and others may need a diet such as Campbell-McBride’s GAPS diet, most of us can make some (relatively) simple adjustments to our diets to get on the right track.

One of the easiest ways of populating your intestinal tract with beneficial bacteria and other microflora (and as Weston Price Homemade picklesdiscovered has been an important part of the diet of most indigenous and traditional populations and cultures) is by eating fermented foods. Foods fermented by natural yeasts and bacteria in the air produce a multitude of beneficial bacteria, and increase the food’s nutritional profile. Since they are partially pre-digested through the fermentation process they are also easier for you to digest. These foods include not only the yogurt, cucumber pickles, and sauerkraut with which we are most familiar, but other pickled vegetables like beets, carrots, and garlic, beverages like kefir and kombucha, and sourdough breads. (Commercial sauerkraut and pickles, unless kept in the refrigerator section of the supermarket, are most likely pickled in vinegar and heated, so they are not fermented foods.)

Another way of improving your microbiome is by taking a good quality probiotics containing a large variety of beneficial bacteria. Another presenter at the summit enumerated some of the important bacteria to look for in quality probiotics, noting the different influences on health for some of them:

  • Bacillus coagulans – reduces abdominal bloating and gas
  • Saccharomyces boulardii – reduces inflammation, elevated TNF Alpha, and Interleukin 6
  • Acidophilus rueteri
  • Biffidobacterium lactis – alleviates constipation and diarrhea
  • Lactobacillus Roselle 52 – breaks down hard-to-digest fibers
  • Lactobacillus rhamnosus
  • Lactobacillus Casei Roselle 215 – makes enzyme that helps breakdown lactose

The following bacteria can be instrumental in alleviating depression, anxiety, and brain fog

  • Lactobacillus helveticus
  • Lactobacillus plantarum ps128
  • Biffidobacterium infantis
  • Biffidobacterium longum

In addition to positive lifestyle changes such as reducing stress and getting adequate sleep, the best ways to support intestinal (and overall) health is by eating a varied diet of good-quality nutrient-dense foods. In addition to eating fermented foods, there were many other dietary principles that the populations that Price examined adhered to that were important to maintaining a well functioning digestive system, overall good health, and a cheerful disposition. Thanks to Price’s research, we can incorporate these principles into our diets as well. Read about them here.

For sources of probiotic/fermented foods and natural and organic products in Israel click here.


[1] Defining the Human Microbiome
[2] Archaea and Fungi of the Human Gut Microbiome: Correlations with Diet and Bacterial Residents
[3] Microbes Help Produce Serotonin in Gut
[4] Defining the Human Microbiome
[5] Gut and Psychology Syndrome, pg. 38

Other Resources:

Fast Facts About the Human Microbiome
What is the Gut Microbiota? What is the Human Microbiome?
Are Probiotics in Your Baby Formula?
The Best Probiotics for Mood: Psychobiotics May Enhance the Gut-Brain Connection
5 Simple Steps to Cure IBS Without Drugs
SIBO – Small Intestine Bacterial Overgrowth


Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Why you want grass-fed butter and where to find it in Israel

Cow in field
Cow in field

Photo: courtesy of Pixabay

One of the important foods that people often search for is butter (חֶמאָה – chem’ah) from pastured cows because it is a rich source of  Vitamins A, D, and K2, as well as many other nutrients. The color of the butter ranges from pale to deep yellow depending on the season, the soil, and the percentage and type of feed that the animals may receive in addition to grass. (A deeper color is indicative of greater amounts of carotenoid pigments from increased amounts of Vitamin A.) Butter from cows grazing on fast growing spring and fall grass is the most nutritious. In fact, Weston Price noted a reduced incidence of heart attacks among people who eat butter made from cows feeding on spring and fall grass.

In 1930, Dr. Weston Price published an interesting paper in the Journal of the American Dental Society. For years, Dr. Price had been analyzing the amounts of vitamin A and vitamin D in butterfat. He noted that these nutrients were most plentiful in the spring and fall, when cows had access to rapidly growing green grass. During the dry winter and summer months, levels of these vitamins in butterfat declined or disappeared completely.

Dr. Price also tabulated the number of deaths from heart attacks in local hospitals. When he plotted these two variables against time on the same graph he found that deaths from heart disease were inversely proportional to the vitamin content in the butter. In other words, when nutrient levels were high, deaths from heart disease were low; and when nutrient levels were low, deaths from heart disease were high. He found this pattern in many different localities, even in areas in the far north where there was only one vitamin peak, in midsummer, due to the short growing season.[1]

Further evidence of the benefits of consuming dairy from pasture raised cows comes from a study done in Costa Rica, where cows are grazed. Here, too, researchers found a lower incidence of heart attacks in people who drank milk from cows that were pastured.

Earlier experiments have shown that cows on a diet of fresh grass produce milk with five times as much of an unsaturated fat called conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) than do cows fed processed grains. Studies in animals have suggested that CLAs can protect the heart, and help in weight loss.

Hannia Campos of the Harvard School of Public Health in Boston and her colleagues found, in a study of 4,000 people, that people with the highest concentrations of CLAs — the top fifth among all participants — had a 36 percent lower risk of heart attack compared to those with the lowest concentrations.

Those findings held true even once the researchers took into account heart disease risk factors such as high blood pressure and smoking.

The new findings suggest that CLA offers heart-healthy benefits that could more than offset the harms of saturated fat in milk, Campos said. [2]

“Because pasture grazing leads to higher CLA in milk, and it is the natural feed for cattle, it seems like more emphasis should be given to this type of feeding,” she told Reuters Health by email. [3]

In addition to the above, butter contains a number of other health promoting constituents such as: lecithin which helps in the proper assimilation of fats; selenium, Vitamin E, and cholesterol which are antioxidants; short and medium chain fatty acids which have anti-tumor and other beneficial properties; iodine which is important for the thyroid; glycospingolipids, a particular type of fatty acid which protects against gastrointestinal infections; and other critical nutrients. [4]

In Israel, despite its dairy industry being considered one of the best and most sophisticated in the world, with cows specifically bred to produce copious amounts of milk, domestic butter is white. This is because Israeli dairy cows are never pastured (beef cattle are).

“While dairy cows elsewhere in the world are able to graze in natural pastures, Israeli cows cannot be left out due to the small size of the country and climate. They are fed with locally grown irrigated forage supplemented by imported grain.” [5]

Tnuva butter

The grazing cattle depicted on this Tnuva butter wrapper must belong to a dairy in another country!

Joshuah Miron who heads the Ruminant Sciences Department and oversees the health and welfare of Israel’s Volcani Center’s herd of 230 dairy cows, says that:

… Israel can grow only 30 percent of the cow’s diet. The rest has to come from somewhere. If the rest is imported, then the price of milk would be very high. Grain costs $340 per ton. Just to feed them, we couldn’t support our cows.

The Volcani Center came up with a nutritious and earth-friendly solution: using some 630,000 tons of wet vegetarian byproducts from the olive oil and food production industries to feed its dairy cows. Otherwise, these byproducts would be treated as waste and taken to the desert and buried… [6]

And according to this recent article, Tnuva (the major dairy company in Israel) has begun giving some cattle feed containing flax which they say improves the animals’ health, as well as their milk’s nutritional profile which is rich in omega 3 fatty acids. It is sold under the brand name Chalav Hameshek.

In any case, it is apparent that the nutrition they receive is not the same as that of their pastured counterparts.

Butter sculpture of boy, cow, and calf

Postcard of John K. Daniels’s butter sculpture of a boy, cow, and calf, Iowa State Fair, 1904. Image: Wikimedia commons

European and other countries (except the US) primarily pasture their dairy cattle, as is evident by the yellow color of the butter. Countries with more temperate climates tend to keep their cattle out to pasture most of the year, while other countries bring their cattle indoors during the winter months. Other circumstances might also mitigate grazing cattle. One company, whose yellow butter is sold in Israel, explained that their butter is produced with milk from several farms including some that are too far from pasture land and are not able to graze their cattle. However, if the ingredient list does not include coloring and the butter is yellow, you can be sure that it has a healthier nutritional profile than white butter.

Fortunately, Israeli consumers interested in purchasing yellow butter from pastured cows can find what they are looking for. The dairy case in many Israeli supermarkets contains both domestic and imported butters, and consumers can find naturally yellow Makabi and Beurre De Normandie from Makabi (chalav Yisrael), Lurpak, Elle & Vire, President, Chemah Hollandit, Chemah (Willi Foods),  and other butters (of varying shades, kosher supervision, and prices) that are imported from France, Denmark, Belgium, Germany, and Holland. [7] 

To find the stores near you that carry yellow butter call: President 03-681-4006, Makabi (cholov Yisrael) 02-583-8368, Lurpak  08-932-1000, Champion 052-249-8865, Elle & Vire 1-800-504-050, Shufersal Hollandit, and Willi Food (cholov Yisrael) 08-932-1017.

American consumers might be interested in these surveys of the best butters available in the States: 30 Great Butters and Butter Tasting.

Sometimes making purchasing decisions based on price is inconsequential and we can feel comfortable buying the less expensive product. Since the domestic butters tend to be less expensive than the imported ones, it may be tempting to purchase the cheaper item in this instance, too. However, as we now know, this is not the case with butter.

For a more detailed discussion of imported European butters in Israel go here. Local (in Israel) contact information for some of the companies selling imported butters can be found here.


[1] What causes heart disease?
[2] For information on the benefits of saturated fats see here.
[3] Is milk from grass-fed cows more heart-healthy?
[4] Why butter is better
[5] The inside story of Israel’s dairy industry
[6] Record making milkers
[7] Champion butter from Ireland, which has been a favorite in many Israeli households that consider it to be superior to the other imported butters, is currently unavailable.

Related articles:

Eating a Weston Price diet in Israel – is it possible?

Related links:

How yellow my butter
Weston Price Trifold butter brochure

How to make butter (and cultured butter!)
Is all butter created equal?
Where to find grass-fed butter (in the US)



Tagged with: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,